So, KDE has been in the shit recently, following their attempts at forging a policy for handling generative AI. I won’t summarise the drama here, because Nate from KDE already did that.
What I will say is that this drama, like a lot of drama surrounding the free and open-source software community, was massively overblown. I looked at the policy that KDE’s contributors were proposing, and it seemed alright. It’s going to be nigh impossible to stop the onslaught of LLM-assisted/generated contributions no matter what side of the coin you land on that debate (and I think the pressure from “KDE for People” is entirely misguided), so to me it looked like KDE set a pragmatic middle ground that prioritised quality regardless. There shouldn’t have been any drama about this, at all, but we live in the age where disagreements turn into… this, I guess.
Frankly, whatever direction KDE goes for, I will trust them to lead its direction as that’s the amount of trust I have for KDE. However this exemplifies a part of why I stopped trying to make the Year of the Linux Desktop happen and moved to Mac instead, because I can’t trust that the ecosystem won’t be prone to drama that is severely holding its projects back. A little bit of disagreement is fine here and there, and you can’t really stop when shit hits the fan occasionally, but lately it feels like the drama surrounding Linux has been constant. It seemed like everyone is fighting over what is best for the ecosystem (probably myself included back then), with ideological extremists in every direction holding it back while Windows and Mac users just get shit done.
You can say it’s a vocal minority, but does it really matter when desktop Linux is driven mainly by ideology? As a result, it’s hard to separate the community from criticism of the thing in question. Alec from Technology Connections shares this view as well.
This isn’t even just about whether LLMs are accepted or not, as I said before I trust KDE regardless. Hell, KDE is the first FOSS project I’ve actually donated money to. They got to the point of building a really good desktop environment without generative AI, they clearly don’t need it. At the same time, I don’t care if they do allow it in the way that was proposed to prioritise quality. For me, it’s about the attitude, and KDE’s got the attitude I get along with most. In my opinion, a balance of their principles while being pragmatic led to them being the de-facto environment for SteamOS’ desktop mode, as well as them getting a good seat on Fedora’s table alongside the GNOME-based Workstation spin, and this is exactly what should’ve been done. A shame all this drama had to ruin it.
Call it parasocial, I don’t care. I just want a bloody good desktop on Linux.
Oh, and if you think KDE is “tainted” because of how this policy was implemented, cut that fucking shit out unless you want a crippling mental illness. Seriously, as someone with OCD symptoms I’m not tolerating that. Go read this.