I didn’t wanna make a post about AI again but, I was inspired by something, and I need to work with that inspiration, innit.
Last night, I had a conversation with my best friend as we devised a new fursona for myself to use in VRChat and beyond. It was a genuinely productive conversation, and to be honest I was getting a bit envious of how he was able to turn the connections I have with people, media, things in general into a potential visual design for the fursona, given that I found myself creatively challenged. Granted, some of my creatively challenged mentality comes from trauma which I’ll need to sort out with a therapist (although he’s already helped crack those walls), but something else popped up during that conversation that resulted in me writing this post: I don’t think the aggressiveness from anti-AI ideologues is helping anyone become more creative.
Over on Bluesky and the Fediverse - both social networks with ideologically charged users - there tends to be constant aggression towards anyone who bothers to use a generative AI tool by the anti-AI movement. I’ve heard the term “pick up the pencil” used a lot in an aggressive tone. Use of LLMs is classed as a “skill issue”. Even what seems like genuine motivation feels spiteful and out of anger, instead of a genuine desire to see people grow and become more creative. While I can understand where the anger is coming from, I hate that people are directing their aggression towards regular people as well as small organisations like KDE (who recently got in the shit trying to devise a policy trying to handle vibe-coded slop - see my post here). I see no inspiration from these ideologues that is genuine, and that is a problem which if the movement does not change course now will only get worse.
Personally, I know for a fact I can draw when I have the motivation. A few months ago I reviewed Tomodachi Life: Living the Dream, the latest iteration of Nintendo’s weird life sim series. I touched on this problematic behaviour by the movement in that review, showing how Nintendo indirectly handled this dilemma by having zero judgement as well as giving those struggling to get things “right” tips on how they can improve. To summarise my thoughts there again, Nintendo not only embraced imperfection, but it also embraced self-improvement. I can be pretty critical of Nintendo, but they’ve approached the problem in a way that works and they deserve their praises there.
To add onto this, this website you’re seeing? The design was of my own making. I didn’t think much of it really. I just figured what I wanted my site to look like, what inspired me, and let myself work with the flow. Learning things about HTML and CSS for those who find it challenging. It’s like a puzzle that can only be solved with your own satisfaction. I think what people forget in the AI hype is that problem solving is inherently a creative task, and I think this is a strong part of what’s causing skill atrophy within software engineers when they rely too hard on LLMs. While LLMs can be good at the menial work, and can help those with crap memory fix what they forgot to change, to rely on them for the problem solving tasks is not a good idea. I see this manifesting with anti-AI as “code is art”, however this is only intended to be part of the aggression rather than anything actually meaningful.
The anti-AI movement could be correct about the ethical problems surrounding generative AI, but because of their behaviour therefore losing allies in the process. It’s been proven time and time again that ideological extremists only drive people away from their causes. This isn’t even hyperbole, I’ve seen this happen a few days ago with the KDE drama where even people who are anti-AI are getting sick of the behaviour. This wasn’t helped by obvious fabrications from Fediverse users misinterpreting the actions and statements from KDE themselves as malicious, in a way that ironically feels malicious to me on their part now. You can be correct, but if you’re deliberately acting like a twat about it you will be treated as if you were wrong. It’s just basic human psychology.
To conclude, the reason I wrote this post is because in an era where AI-generated slop imagery is being shoved in people’s faces, we need to inspire the next generations of artists, and in my opinion the aggressive tactics I’ve seen from anti-AI ideologues simply hasn’t worked. For that reason, you can justify all you want to me about why you’re being angry and aggressive towards random people and small organisations on the Internet, but you’ll be falling on very deaf ears. That conversation I’ve had with my friend was able to inspire me to break down the walls that were killing my creativity more than anyone who’s staunchly in this movement angrily posting on irrelevant social platforms or sniffing their own farts have ever done, and this post - and this website as a whole - is definitive proof of that.